Атакуюче слово
Saved in:
| Published in: | Український історичний журнал |
|---|---|
| Date: | 1987 |
| Main Author: | |
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | Ukrainian |
| Published: |
Інститут історії України НАН України
1987
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://nasplib.isofts.kiev.ua/handle/123456789/213412 |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
|
| Journal Title: | Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine |
| Cite this: | Атакуюче слово / Б.Д. Машталярчук // Український історичний журнал. — 1987. — № 10. — С. 153–155. — укр. |
Institution
Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine| _version_ | 1860298373828968448 |
|---|---|
| author | Машталярчук, Б.Д. |
| author_facet | Машталярчук, Б.Д. |
| citation_txt | Атакуюче слово / Б.Д. Машталярчук // Український історичний журнал. — 1987. — № 10. — С. 153–155. — укр. |
| collection | DSpace DC |
| container_title | Український історичний журнал |
| first_indexed | 2026-03-21T18:46:19Z |
| format | Article |
| fulltext |
BapTo 6yjio 6 a o iio b h h th k o p o tk h m h aHo-
TauiHMii, nxi jonoMorjin 6 CTŷ eHTaM opi-
eHTyßaTHCH B 3HaHHl’A xijIbXOCTi KHHr 3 TeMH.
Bxa3yx)HH cepeu pexoMeHAOBaHo! jiiTepaTy-
PH TBOpH KJiaCHKiß MapXCH3My-JieHiHi3My, aB-
Topn H33HBaiOTb npaui, HeoöxiAHi cTVAeHTaM
AJia onpamoBanHH i o6Me>xyK>TbCH TijibXH
BKa3iBKOK> Ha xijIbXiCTb CTOpiHOK KOJKHOrO 3
BHÄaHb. OiiA Mam Ha yßa3i, mo neprno-
KypCHHKaM Ba>KKO 3H3HTH CTOpiHKH 3 BH-
CJIOBJieHHMH ÄyMKaMH moao TeMH, HXa BHB-
HaeTbCH. EaxcaHo 6y.no 6 Bxa3aTH KOHKpeTHi
cropiHKH TBopy, a He oßMexcyBaTHCH <j)Op-
MajibHHM floro 6i6jiiorpa(J)iHH]!M onwcoM.
B uuiOMy aBTopn BAajio BHópajin TeMH
npaKTHHHHX (ceMinapcbKHx) 3aHHTb. Bohh
OXOnJUOIOTb B3)KJIHßi npOÖJieMH iCTOpil CTa-
pOÄaBHboro cßiTy i, mo Ay>xe BaxuinBO,
rpyHTyioTbCH Ha cepfio3HHX ÄJKepejiax. Ha
xtajib, no3a yßaroio aßTopiß 3aJiHUiH;iHCH nn-
T3HHH 3 icTopil cTapoAaBHboro cprry nep-
iuol nojioBHHH I t h c . h . e. 3 icTOpiT Grapo-
ATAKVIOHE CJIOBO
MaKCUMi jK 77. 77.
IJpeca yPCP y öopoTböi
npOTU KAepUKÜAbHOZO ÜHTUK0MlJH.i3My.
K. : H üijk. dijMKa, 1986.— 152 c.
H k bUomo, cTpHÄHeM cynacHOro xjiepH-
KajibHoro 3HTHK0MyHi3My Ta iMnepia,ii3My,
IX OCHOBHHM 3MiCT0M € aHTIipaflHHlUHHa.
ToM y 6opOTb6a npoTH xjiepHxajibHoro aHTH-
K0MyHi3My, po3BiHHyßaHHH fioro iAeßHHx oc-
hob i cynacHoT npaKTHKH e aKTyajibHHM 3aB-
AHhhhm paAHHCbKoi npecu, npo mo i fueTbCH
y MOHorpa^il xanAHAaTa ictophhhhx HayK,
CTapmoro HayKOBOro cnißpoÖiTHHxa iHCTHTy-
Ty cycnijibHux Hayx AH YPCP n. Ö. M a x -
CHMyxa. Flpaufl He Mae anajioriß He JiHine 3a T3K0K) nocTaHOBKOfo npoöJieMH, a h 3a
xoMnjiexcHHM xapaxTepoM TI po3rjiHAy.
BwxoHaHa Bona Ha CTHxy couiojioril, 3a-
rajibHoI icTopil, icTopil A Teopil paAHHCbxol
npecH, i b ubOMy oAHe 3 II aoctoihctb.
Abtop 3ocepennB yßary Ha cnpocTyßaHHi
npecoio xjiepHxajibHHX ^ajibCHc^ixauifi Hay-
xoboto aTel3Mv Ta craHOBuma pejiiril A
uepxBH b CPĆP, noxa3ye pojib npecn y
P03BiHHaHHi OÖAVAHHX XJiepHXajIbHHX XOH-
uenuiA npo 3HaqeHHH pejiirii, ouiHK)e e(j>ex-
THBHicTb xoHTpnponaraHAH. Taxa nocra-
HOBxa npoöJieMH BHMarajia peTejibHOro y3a-
rajibHeHHH AOCBiAy npecw ( hx no3HTHBHoro,
Tax i AonymeHHX noMHJiox) y ßopoTböi npo
TH x^epHxajii3My, BHCBiTJieHHH hobhx <j)opM
i MeTOAlB II poßOTH, TeHAeHUiA, p03TJIHAy
HcaHpoBoI najiiTpn Ta jirrepaTypHoro pißHH
nyßjiixauiA i, 3po3yMi.no, aHa;ii3y e<f>exTHB-
HOCTi BHCTyniß, 3 HHM AOCJliAHHX CnpaBHBCH
b ui-noMy ycnimHO, 3P06hbhih pha uiHHHX
HayKOBO-npaKTHMHHX BHCHOBXiß.
HacaMnepen, cnnpaxHiHCb Ha pe3y;ibTaTH
couiojioriMHHX AoaniAJxeHb, npoßeACHHX y 3a-
xiAHOMy perioHi pecnyÖJiixn cnijibHo 3 Hay-
kobuhmh iHCTHTyTy cycniAbHHx Hayx, aBTOp
3P0ÖHB BaJKJIHBHft ajih xoHuenuil ra3eTHo!
AaBHboro CxoAy e jiHiiie Aßi TeMH, nxi c t o -
cyx)TbCH CTapoAaBHboro ĆrwnTy i Crapo-
AaBHboI Baßi^oHil. OAHax Hi Ipany, Hi
I h a ü , Hi KnTax) b npaxTiixyMi neMae. npo-
Te ue 36araTHJio 6 floro i CTBOpHAO m o>x -
JlHBiCTb BHÖOpy, nepiOAHHHOrO OHOBJieHHH
TeMaTHXH 33HHTb. AßTopaM BapTO 6yA0 6
nOAyMaTH i npo cTBopeHHH HeoöxiAHOro Me-
TOAHHHoro anapaTV a o a b h h x TexcTiß. Aznxe
cryAeHT noBHHeH OAepncaTn xoHxpeTHi Bxa-
3ißKH: mo pOßHTH i3 3anponOHOßaHHMH AO
3aHHTb MaTepiâ aMH, mo b hh x e to jio b h h m ,
3 HHM IX nOpißHKJBaTH TOmO.
B ui;ioMy neoöxiAHO niAXpecjiiiTH, mo pe-
ueH30BaHa xnnra e neBHHM bkji3a o m y pa-
AHHCbxy yxpalHCbxy HaBHajibHy A MeTOAmncy
AiTepaTypy. BoHa rapHo 0(J)opMAeHa: II 06 -
K.iaAHHKH, XyAOJKIli 3aCTaBXH AO XOJXHOl
TeMH CBiAHaTb npo Bucoxy BHAaBHHHy i no-
:iirpact)iHHy xy^bTypy.
I. O. T J I H T O B (JlbBiß)
nponaraHAH bhciiobox npo Te, mo cynacHa
HHTaubxa ay.THTopiH nepeöyßae Ha hxi*cho
icobomv eTani cnpufiHHTTH BMimenHX y npeci
MaTepia.iiß. Ha nijibne Micue nocTaßjieHO
nyöjiixauil HayxOBO-nyßjiinHCTHHHoro xapax-
Tepy A Ti, b hxiix miTaHHH Teopil opraHiHHO
n0B*H3yi0TbCH 3 npaXTHHHHMH 33BAaHHHMH
(J)OpMyßaHHH CBiTOrAHAy H0 B01 AIOAHHH, co -
uiajibHO-exoHOMiHHOro p03BHTxy cycniAb-
CTßa. BMOTiiBOßaHicTb Taxoro BHCHOBxy niA-
TBepA^yeTbCH A t h m , mo y nponaraHAHCT-
cbxnx axuinx xjiepHxaAbHoro a»iTHX0MyHi3My
niTxo npocToxyxjTbCH Asa ocHOBHi acnexTH*.
COUiaAbHO-nOJliTHHHHA i CßiTOrAHÄHHA.
ÄTeiCTHHHy CnpHMOBaHiCTb, HX BHnjIHBae 3
AOCAiAÄeHHH, M3K)Tb He jiHme nyöjiixauil
npo iAeoaorix) Ta nojiiTHxy uepxBH. y koh-
TexcTi ra3eTH nopnA 3 BHCTynaMH cyTO
aTelcTHHHoro xapaxTepy 3HanH0 6iJibinoI
ßarn Ha6yBax)Tb TeopeTimHi A nponaraHAH-
CTCbxi cTaTTi 3 nHTaHb jieHiHCbxol Hauio-
HajIbHOl nOAiTIIXH, APV>k6h HapOAiß, BH-
xpHTTH ßopojxol iAeojioril yxpalHCbxoro 6yp-
>xya3Horo nam’0HaAi3My.
IÜHpoxo BHCßiT.ieHo B npaui xonTpnpona-
raHAHCTCbxy AinJibHicTb npecH, mo rpyHTyen»-
ch Ha MeTOAOjioriHHiA nacTaHOBi B. I. Jle-
HiHa npo neo6xiAHicTb TicHO noBłH3yB3TH
nponaraHAV HayxoBoro xoMyHi3My 3 Aoro
33XHCT0M Ta oxopoHOK) ßiA nepexpyneHb i
AajibmHM po3BHTxoM npoAeTapcbxoi iAeo-
Aoril — MapxcH3My
A b to p Aae AeTaAbHHH p o 3t a h a xoHTpnpo-
naraHAHCTCbXHX BHCTyniß npecn, 30xpeMa
no T3KHX HanpHMax, hx b h x p h t th 6 y p * y -
a3HHX i xAepwxaAbHHX (J)aAbCH(J)ixauiA Mapx-
CH3My-JieHiHi3My, KAacoßa cyTb xoMyHicTHH-
h o I Ta peJiiriAHoI iAeoAoriA, Ix HecyMicHicTb
i npoTHJiexcHicTb y niAxoAi a o m'AeA, iAea^iß
cycnuibCTBa Ta ocoßncTOCTi, 3HaqeHHH npaui,
macTH, CBOÓOAH, piBHOcTi, ßpaTepcTBa B
HCHTTi AK>AHHH.
1 ähb.: JleHiH B. I. rioAiTHHHa ariTauin
i «XAafcOBa Toqxa 3opy* // rioBHe 3i6p. tbo-
piß. — T. 6.—C. 253.
KjiepHKaJlbHa aHTHpaAHHIUHHa BHHBAH€Tb-
ca b cTapaHHO npoAyMaHHx iAeoAoriqHHx
AHBepciax cneucAyxcö iMnepiajiicTHRHHX Aep-
JK3B. ToMy b KOHTpnponaraHAHCTCbKifl po-
ÖOTi ra3eT aBTop niAKpecAioe BaxcAHBHfi ac-
neKT: CAiA AaBaTH BiAciq no KO*HOMy koh-
KpeTHOMy cJjaKTy öpexHi, Hamieniß, nepeupy-
qeHb i t. n. FIpHHOMy KOHipnponaraHAy Ha-
jiewiiTb BecTH y abox HanpaMax: 30BHiin-
HbOMy i BHyTpiuiHbOMy, 3a6e3neqyioqH Ix
cHCTeMiiicTb, nocjiiAOBHicTb, rJiHóOKy KOMne-
TeHTHicTb i apryMeHTOBaHidb 3 o6ob'h3KO-
bhm BpaxyBaHHHM KOHKpeTHOi CHTyauil B
pi3HHx panoHax KpalHH i cryneHH BiuiHBy
6ypxcya3Ho! nponaraHAH Ha pi3Hi rpynn Ha-
C6ABHHH.
3ßiACH BHnAHBae BaXCAHBHfi BHCHOBOK, IAO
po3paxoByB3TH Ha äaacaHHft e(J)eKT MOXHa
AHiue TOAi, kojih KOHTpnponaraHAa Mae ui-
AecnpHMOBaHHH xapaKTep i aApecyeTbca
AOópe 3HaHift ayAHTopil. ToMy couioAoriq-
HHMH AOCAiAJKeHHHMH TpeÖa OXOnAIOBaTH
AeAaAi öiAbini periOHH ft uiHpoxi BepcTBH Ha-
CejieHHH, BHHBAHTH 3MiHH B fiOrO HaCTpOHX,
norAHAax i t. a.
UiHHHM y npaui n. n. MaKCHMyxa e ft
Te, mo aBTop BKa3ye Axcepê a a a h niuro-
t o b k h ra3eTHHX KOHTpnponaraHAHCTCbKHx
nyÖAiKauift. Ue — apxißHi AOKyMeHTH, mo-
A6HHHKH AiHHlB yHiaTCbKOl UepKBH, (J)aAb-
mHBKH 3 apxißiß JUenTHUbKOro, AOKyMeHTH
cniftMaHHX Ha rapaqoMy KAepnKaAbHHX eMi-
CapiB, 3aBAaHHH K0HTpp03BiA0K, C(J)aAbCH-
4)iKOBaHi Ta mcnipoBani 3a BiAnOBiAHy nAaT-
HIO AHCTH HenOpaAHHX AIOAeft. KAep HK3 AbH a
KOHTpaäaHAa, npoBOKauiftHa i HaKAenHHUbKa
iH(|)OpMauiH, 3aflBH KOAHIDHIX BipyiOHHX TO-
mo. Taxe uiHpoKe b h k o p h c t3hhh u*epeA
poÖHTb MaTepiaAH a o k 330bhm h ft Hecnpo-
CTOBHHMH.y MOHOrpa(J)ii p03rAHAai0TbCH OCHOBHi Ha-
IipflMH, no HKHX KAepHK3AH p03ropTaK>Tb Ha-
KAemiHUbKi KaMnaHil ft aiaKH Ha noAiTHKy
KÜPC i PaAHHCbKoI AepxcaBH iu o a o peAi-
r i! Ta uepKBH, eraHOBHiua peAiril ft ßipyio-
h h x ß CPCP, CBOÖOAH coßicTi ft npaß a io -
AHHH i t . n. Hnpa3 ui miTaHHa ft HeoöxiAHO
ßpaxoByßaTii b Harnift KOHTpnponaraHAi.
BajKAiiBHMH e peKOMeHAauii iu o a o m o jk a h -
BOCTefi Ta HaftAOuiAbHiuiHx cnocoöiß i MeTO-
Aiß ra3eTnoI nponaraHAH. PUeTbca npo
BMilUeHHH AOßipOK, BeAeHHH nOCTifiHHX i
3M1HHHX pyöpHK, 3aAyMeHHH AO ynacTi b
HanncaHHi MaTepiaAiß npeACTaßHHKiß pi3HHx
KaTeropifl HaceAeHHH i3 ctpepH MaTepiaAbHo-
ro BHpoÖHHUTßa, KyAbTypn. BiA3HaneHO
OCOÖAHBO BHCOKy e(J)eKTHBHiCTb onepaTHBHHX
nyóAiKauifi no rapaqnx CAiAax aßaHTiop
iAefiHHx npoTHBHHKiß. y MOHorpac|)ii p03-
KpHTO IUHpOKi MOHCAHBOCTi ft npnftOMH ap-
ryMeHTauil nyÖAiKauift Ha ocHOBi Teoperaq-
HHX nOAOJKeHb KAaCHKlß MapKCH3My-AeHlHi3My,
BHA3THHX AiHHiß napTÜ i PaAHHCbKOl Aep-
xcaßH, KoHCTHTyui! CPCP Ta iHUinx a o -
KyMeHTiß.
T a HÓOKO BHHKaiOHH B iCTOpHHHy npaKTH-
Ky peAiriftHoI nponaraHAH, aBTop po3KpHBae
MeTOAHKy KAepHKaAbHHX niATaCOBOK i (J)aAb-
CH(t)iKauift iCTOpHMHHX (JjaKTiB, MeTa HKHX—
nepeKOHam AiOAefi, hi’6h uepKBa i b MHHy-
AOMyt ft Tenep ßiuirpae nporpecHBHy pOAb,
nOCißTH iAK)3ilO eAHOCTi UepKOBHOl nOAlTHKH
3 OÖ'eKTHBHHM 3MiCT0M iCTOpil. OcOÓAHBO
B3>KAHBHM y UbOMV nAaßi € nOAiTHHlie p03-
BiHHaHHa uepKBH ft AyXOBeHCTBa, BHKpHTTa
Ix KAacoBoI cyTi.
CAiA 333HaqHTH, luo aBTop BHKOpHCTOBye
npecy i an eMnipHHHy 6a3y, i aK icTopHHHe
AHCepeAO, KOAH ftAeTbCa npO BHCBiTAeHHH
cJ)aKTiß HeAaAeKoro MHHyAoro.
3 orAauy Ha ue 3HaaHy uiHHicTb aBAae
aHaAi3 nyÓAiKauift, y hkhx npeca BHKpHBaxa
raHeöHi 3b’h3kh rpeKo-KaTOAHUbKOl uepKBH
3 (J)auiH3MOM niA nac BeAHKOi BiTqH3HaH0l
BiftHH: npaMe cnißpoöiTHHUTBO AyxoßeHCTBa
3 cfraimicTaMH, ftoro yaacTb y BCTaHOBAeHHi
«HOBoro nopaAKy» Ha oxynoBaHHx 3eMxax, y
MicueBHX opraHax oKynauiftHo! BAaAH, rpa-
ÖiXCHHUbKHX noöopax i3 CeAHH Ha KOpHCTb
oKynaHTiB, y KpHBaßnx p03npaßax, nma-
ryHCbKa AiHAbHicTb b iHTepecax (JjauiHCTCbKoI
HiMeHHHHH, BHKOHaHHa «nacTHpHMH» 060-
B’a3KiB areHTiß CR i recrano, Aonoiiora
cjjauiHCTaM b opraHi3aui! ßiflcbKOBHX, Ka*
paAbHHX Ta OXOpOHHHX <))OpMyBaHb 3 HHCA8
yKpaiHCbKHX 6yp>Kya3HHX HauioHaAicTiß.
Po3KpHBaioqH THyaKe npHCTocyßaHHa peai-
ril äo peaAbHoI o6ct3hobkh, ao cycniAbHHX
3MiH, aBTop niAKpecAKDe Tany 33K0H0Mip*
HicTb: aHTHKOMyHicTHHHa nponaraHAa cy-
nacHoro KAepHKaAi*3My bcahkoio Mipoio 3aAe*
ÄHTb BiA MijKHapoAHoi CHTyauil Ta iAeft,
nporoAouiyBaHHX iepapxaMH uepKBH ft iAeo-
AoraMH iMnepiaAi3My. BoHa 3acTocoBye pi3Hi
cxeMH iAeoAoriaHOi excnaHcil aHTHK0MyHi3My,
30KpeMa KOHuenuii «niAKAioqeHHa>, mo 6a-
3yeTbca Ha arpecuBHift AOKTpHHi €H3BeACHHa
moctib», po3ropTaHHa «ncHXOAoriqHoi BiftHH»
i moHaftmHpuie BHKopHCTaHHa b Hifi 3aaA0-
>KeHHX uiTaMniß — «roHiHHa Ha xphcthhh»,
«nopymeHHa» cboÖoah coßicTi y PauflHCbKOMy
Coi03i Ta iH.
Abtop poÖHTb cnpoöy BH3HaqHTH ec})eK-
THBHicTb HayKOBO-aTelcTHHHOi nponaraHAH
3a T3KHMH napaMeTpaMH, aK CBiAOMicTb i
nOBeuiHKa Aioueft, Ha ocHOBi pe3yAbTaTiß
couioAoriqHHX AOCAiuaceHb i cnißCTaBAeHHa Ix
3 qacTOTOio nyÓAiKauift pi3H»x npoÓAeMHO-
TeMaTnqHHX HanpaMiß, ypaxyßaHHa Micue-
bhx vmob, KOHKpeTHOi CHTyauil b perioHi.
CAiu BiA3HaqiiTH BHHaTKOBy HayKOBy cyM-
AiHHiCTb AOCAiAHHKa: HHM BHBHeHO KOHCHHH
HOMep ra3eTH, BpaxoBaHO Bei MaTepiaAH Bia
iH(J)opMauifiHo! 3aMiTKH äo aHaAiTHqHHX *aH-
piß. U e A3AO MOHCAHBiCTb 3pOÖHTH fl KOH-
KpeTHi bhchobkh, HanpHKAaA, npo Te, mo
«3aco6 aM MacoBoi incpopMauil JlbBißmHHH,
iBaHo-OpanKiBmHHH, 3aKapnaTCbKOl i TepHO-
niAbcbKOi oóAacTefi caia... nociiAHTH yßary
AO nHTaHb p03BiHqaHHa K3TOAHUH3My, 30-
KpeMa BHKpHTTa aHTHHapoAHOi poAi rpeKO-
KaTOAHUbKOl uepKBH, nOCHAHTH HayKOBy
KpHTHKy iHmnx BipoßqeHb, nepeuyciM npa-
BOCA3B*a, aKoro AOTpHMyeTbca nepeBaxcHa
ÓiAbmicTb Bipyjoqnx» (c. 131). A BH3HaqeH-
Ha miTOMoI Barn nyöAiKauifi aTelcTHqHo!
TeMaTHKH AonoMOHce b KopnryBaHHi ra3eT-
hhx KaMnaiiift, noAOAaiiHi oAHoßiquocTi npo
naraHAH.
B npaui HaBeAeHO AaHi npo BnAHB npecH
Ha BiAxiA BipyioMiix BiA peAiril (Ha 3acoÓH
MacoBoi iH^opMauil npunauae 66,4%), Ta,
Ha xaAb, ui AaHi BiuipBaHi b \ r eMnipunHo!
6a3H AOCAiAHHKa. Bohh cTocyiOTbca couio-
AoriqHHX AOCAiu>KeHb BopoHe3bKoro iHCTH-
TyTy nayKOBoro aTel3My AKaueMil cycniAb-
hhx HayK npn U K K Ü P C . Jlnuie couiOAO-
riqHi AOCAiA>KeHHa KacpeupH icTopil i Teopil
aiel3My KnIßCbKoro ymBepcitTeTy Ta IßaHO-
OpaHKiBCbKoro BiAAi.iy aiei3My iHCTHTyTy
<ł>i/ioco<t>ii AH yPCP 3B'B3aui 3 6a3010 a o c -
AiAweHHB aBTOpa, upoTe bohh cTocyiOTbca
ouiHKH BipyiomiMH pejiirifiiinx AorM, a hc
BiAxoAy bi*a peAiril. ZIa h KOHTpnponaraHAH
ui Aaiii He MoxcyTb 6yTH BaroMHMH me A
t o m y , mo, HanpiiKjiaA, paAio BaTixaHy pa-
nime b nepeAanax BHKopHCTOByßajio 6uibme
AOrMaTHHHHX üHTailb, «4>aKTiB» iCTOpil, mo
M3AH lAeaAi3yBaTH xaTOAHiXH3M, a Tenep
ćiAbine yßarn npnAiAHe cynacHift npoöJieua-
THui. A b to p npocrexcye b h a h b 3aco6iB M a -
coboT iH(|>opMauiI AHUie Ha BiAxiA Bipyxmix
BiA uepKOBHol 06ph a o b o c t! A pHTyajiiB, Ta
ue me He 03Hanae noBHoro po3pnBy 3 pe-
.iiri€K).
Ha ociioBi npaBHAbHo! MeTOAOJiortaHol Te-
3H npo Te, mo oahhm 3 BHpiuiaAbHHX no-
KasHHKiB eipeKTHBHOCTi poóoTH 3aco6iB
MacoBoI iH$opMauiI e iAeAHO-noAinniHa
cnpHMOBaHicTb MaTepiâ iB, aBTop, Ha xcajib,
Ti.ibKH KOHCTaTye, mo «nepeBaxcHa óiAbinicTb
Tx BiAnoBiAae BHMorau napTiAHOcri i Hayxo-
BOCTi», noAax)HH Ha niATBepAXceHHH nboro
a nine HH3xy ra3eTHHx 3arojiOBxiB (c. 129).
y TaxnA xce cnoció apryMeHTyeTbcn A Te3a
npo AOAepncaHHH npHHUHny npaBAHBOcri
(c. 130). OieBHAHO, Tyr i c/iiA 6yxo no-
xa3aTH xapaxTepm noMHAXH b ny&iixauinx
na mol npecH, moó bhkaiomhth Ix noBTOpeH-
hh. Bo m ca Me ra3eTHi MaTepiajiH A TBopn
AKTyAJJbHI nPOBJIEMH KPHTHKH
BVP)KyA3HOrO HAUIOHAJII3My
B u a ko e 10. C.
MerodoAoeunecKue ocnoeti rcpuTUKU
6ypotcya3HOZo hqhuohqausmq .
K . : Butąa uikoaü, 1985.— 183 c.
B yMOBax öeaxoMnpoMicHol öopoTbön Mixe
couiaAi3MOM i xaniTajii3MOM, MapxcH3MOM-
AeHiHi3MOM i 6ypxcya3HOio iAeoAonex) c$epa
Uboro npoTHöopcTBa oxonjix>e npaxTHHHo bcI
HBHma i npouecH cycnijibHO-nojiiTHHHoro xcht-
th, 3oxpeMa, HauioHaAbHe nHTaHHH. iMne-
piajiicritmia nponaraHAa HaAae AoMy oco6-
AHBOrO 3HaqOHHH. 06’eKTHBHy CKAaAHiCTb
npoÖJieMH no-CBoeMy HaMaraxvrbCH bhkoph-
CTaTH peaxuiAm xojia Ha 3axoAi. Ro peni,
AiTepaTypa, npHCBHqena uiA TeMaTHui, cnpaa-
Ai neocHXtHa. BiAbuiicTb 6ypxcya3HHX yne-
11 hx y>xe ne MOxeyTb oÖiATHCH 6e3 micth-
(pixauil AaHoro nHTaHHH, 6e3ynHHmix aTax
na npoAerapcbKHH iiiTepHauioHa:ii3M, (pajib-
cmJjixauiT TeopeTHHHoro i npaxTHHHOro a o c-
niAy po3B’H3anHH HauioiiaAbHHx npoÖAeM y
nauiiA xpalHi.
3 orjinay Ha ue axTyaAbiiicTb Monorpacpil
IO. C. BiiAKOBa He3anepeMHa. 3MicTOBHHA
aHaAi3 cyTHOCTi ÖypxcyaaHO-HauionaAicTHHHHX
KOHuenuiA, bhkoh8hhh amopoM na ocHOßi
MapXClICTCbXO-AeHiHCbKHX MeTOAOAÔ iHHHX
npHHunniB, HecnpocTOBHo AOBOAHTb, mo Hay-
KOBO-TeOpeTHHHa HecnpOMOXCHiCTb 4>aAbCH(|)i-
xaTopcbKHX «TeopiA» Hauil i Hauiona;ibHHX
BiAHOCHH aVMOBAeiia He Aiune cK/iajHicno
AiTepaTypn, b hxhx AonycxaeTbcn HeuiTxicTb
BHKJiaAy iAeAHHX i CBiTOrJIHAHHX n03Hu!A,
OepyTbCH Ha 036poehhh nponaraHAOK) xxe-
PHKaAbHOrO aHTHKOMyHißMy.
nponaraHAHCTCbxa ÖopoTböa 3 pejiiriex) hk
OCOÖAHBHM CT3HOM i HaCTpO€M, OCOÖAHBOK)
cnpHMOBaHicTK) noHyrrie He TepnHTb ma6-
AOHy, cyxocri, xa3eHmHHH, BHMarae 3acrro-
cyBaHHH b nyöAixauinx eMouiAnoro (paxTO-
pa, o6pa3HOCTi, mo6 bohh BnAHBaAH He AHme
Ha po3yM, a A Ha noHyrrn akdahhh. Oahbk
y peueH30BaHiA npaui MaAxce Bei npoÖAeMH
MaAcrepHocTi ApyxoBaHoI nponaraHAH 3Be-
AeHO AO nOHHTTH nyÖAiUHCTHHHOCTl 6e3 p03-
xpHTTH xapaxTepHHX npHHOMiß, 6e3 anajiisy
cpaxoBOl BnpaBHocri raaeTHpiß.
HaAMipHO 3axonHBCH aßTop MOHorpaipil
nepejiixoM pyöpnx, TeMaTHHHHx cTOpiHOx
Tomo. PyöpHKH, hx BiAOMo, AHnie AO neB-
hoI MipH p03xpHBax)Tb 3MicT BHCTyniB npecii,
xoua A noBHHHi HecTH cmhcaobc HaßaHTa-
XCeHHH, 6yTH HaCTHHOK) iH(J)OpMaTHBHOl CHCTe-
mh, Ta npo ue b npaui HaBiTb He 3raAyeTbCH.
BiAOMo Taxoxc, mo npaxTHxa nyÖJiixauiA
TeMaTHHHHX CTOpiHOK M8€ HX n03HTHBHiv TBK
i HeraTHBHi MOMeHTH. OAHax, yaaraAbHHßmn
ßce no3HTHBHe b poöOTi npecH, aßTop He
noxa3aB II xapaxTepHHX HeAOxixiB, He ox-
peCAHB HOBHX npOÖACMHHX HanpHMiB TT Al-
HAbHOCTl*.
B. R . MAUITAJIHPHyK (JIbbIb)
uhx (freHOMeHiß. ToAOBHy poAb npn ubOMy
BiAirpae KAacoBO-iAeoAoriHHa 3auixaBJieHicn>
anoAoreTiB xaniTaxi3My y npHHaAHOMy a^h
ceöe CßiTAi c<J>opMyjix>BaTH peuenTH €po3B*H-
33HHH» HauiOHaAbHOrO nHTaHHH B yMOBax
aHTaroHicTHHHoro cycnixbcrBa, AOBecm «He-
MiuiyHicTb» Ta «yHiBepcajibHicTb» MixcHauio-
lia.lbllllX KOH(pAiKTiB.
HeßiA'eMHOio cka8aobok) macTHHOK) Aia-
AeKTHKo-MaTepiaxicTHMHOl iAeoAoril e npHH-
unn icit>pH3My, 38bahkh HKOMy ßiAöyßaeTbCH
KOHxpeTH3auiH 3araAbHOl (pixoco^cbxol toh-
kh 3opy. FIpoTe «AOCAiAHceHHH 6ypxcya3Horo
HauionaAißMy 3 no3Hui! npHHUHny icT0pH3-
My, — cAyuiHo 3ayßaxcye aBTop, — He cxiA
3B0AHTH AO npocToro BiATBopeHüH Aoro a»Ac-
hok) icTopiex). TiAbKH nicAH Toro, xoah
BCTaHOBjiem HeoÖxiAHi 3b'h3Kh Aoro nxicuoro
CTaHy, mo 3yM0BJI10K)Tb iCTOpiK) BHHHKHeHHH
A eBOAiouil HauioHaAi3My, 3axoHH, 3riAH0
3 HKJIMH B HbOMy B1A6yBaK)TbCH 3MiHH, MOXC-
ahbo po3xpHTH AiucHy cyTHicTb 6ypxcya3HO-
ro nauioHaAi3My, 3po3yMiTH cneuHtpixy Aoro
3MicTy i abth xapaxTepHCTHxy couiaxbHHX
(J)yHXuiA> (c. 41).
"Abtop aHaAi3ye i apryMeHTOßaHO xphth-
Kye pi3Hi biihbh 6ypxcya3Horo HauioHaAi3My,
BHKopHCTOByioMH xaTeropix) npaxTHKH. y cy-
uacHtix yMOBax MeTOAOAoriHHe 3HaneHHH oc-
TaiiHboI hx xpiiTepiio iCTHHii, niAXpecAioe bIh,
iieyxHAbHo 3pocTa€. Ue 3yMOBAeHe A»iHaMi3-
mom cycniAbHifx npoueeiß, ycxAaAHeHHHM
couiajibHHX cTpyxTyp, 3arocrpeHHHM iAeoxo-
riuHOi GopoTbÖH Ha Mi>KHapoAi(iA apeHi. B
npaKTHMHiA AiHAbHOcri 6ypxcya3HO-HauiOHa-
.licTiimnix uempiß norAHÖAioeTbCH TeHAenuin
|
| id | nasplib_isofts_kiev_ua-123456789-213412 |
| institution | Digital Library of Periodicals of National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine |
| issn | 0130-5247 |
| language | Ukrainian |
| last_indexed | 2026-03-21T18:46:19Z |
| publishDate | 1987 |
| publisher | Інститут історії України НАН України |
| record_format | dspace |
| spelling | Машталярчук, Б.Д. 2026-02-17T15:35:07Z 1987 Атакуюче слово / Б.Д. Машталярчук // Український історичний журнал. — 1987. — № 10. — С. 153–155. — укр. 0130-5247 https://nasplib.isofts.kiev.ua/handle/123456789/213412 uk Інститут історії України НАН України Український історичний журнал Критика та бібліографія Атакуюче слово Атакующее слово Article published earlier |
| spellingShingle | Атакуюче слово Машталярчук, Б.Д. Критика та бібліографія |
| title | Атакуюче слово |
| title_alt | Атакующее слово |
| title_full | Атакуюче слово |
| title_fullStr | Атакуюче слово |
| title_full_unstemmed | Атакуюче слово |
| title_short | Атакуюче слово |
| title_sort | атакуюче слово |
| topic | Критика та бібліографія |
| topic_facet | Критика та бібліографія |
| url | https://nasplib.isofts.kiev.ua/handle/123456789/213412 |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT maštalârčukbd atakuûčeslovo AT maštalârčukbd atakuûŝeeslovo |