STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review)

  The review article presents the results of systematic research by the authors of a number of heterometals and mixed-ligand 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates, their structure, biological and pharmacological properties. It was observed, that hexanuclear cyclic complex anions o...

Повний опис

Збережено в:
Бібліографічні деталі
Дата:2024
Автори: Martsynko, Olena, Seifullina, Inna, Finik, Оlena, Tsymbaliuk, Kyrylo
Формат: Стаття
Мова:Англійська
Опубліковано: V.I.Vernadsky Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry 2024
Онлайн доступ:https://ucj.org.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/688
Теги: Додати тег
Немає тегів, Будьте першим, хто поставить тег для цього запису!
Назва журналу:Ukrainian Chemistry Journal
Завантажити файл: Pdf

Репозитарії

Ukrainian Chemistry Journal
_version_ 1871466074089717760
author Martsynko, Olena
Seifullina, Inna
Finik, Оlena
Tsymbaliuk, Kyrylo
author_facet Martsynko, Olena
Seifullina, Inna
Finik, Оlena
Tsymbaliuk, Kyrylo
author_institution_txt_mv [ { "author": "Olena Martsynko", "institution": "Odesa I. I. Mechnikov National University, Dvoryanska St., 2, Odesa, 65082, Ukraine" }, { "author": "Inna Seifullina", "institution": "Doctor of Chemical Sciences, Professor, Professor of the Department of Inorganic Chemistry and Chemical Education; Odesa I.I. Mechnikov National University, Dvoryanska St., 2, Odesa, 65082, Ukraine." }, { "author": "Оlena Finik", "institution": "Chemist, Limited Liability Company LLC "INSPECTORAT UKRAINE", Udilny Lane, 1, Odesa, 65044, Ukraine." }, { "author": "Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk", "institution": "PhD-student, Odesa I.I. Mechnikov National University, Dvoryanska St., 2, Odesa, 65082, Ukraine and chemist in Limited Liability Company LLC "INSPECTORAT UKRAINE", Udilny Lane, 1, Odesa, 65044, Ukraine." } ]
author_sort Martsynko, Olena
baseUrl_str https://ucj.org.ua/index.php/journal/oai
collection OJS
datestamp_date 2026-07-22T08:23:55Z
description   The review article presents the results of systematic research by the authors of a number of heterometals and mixed-ligand 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates, their structure, biological and pharmacological properties. It was observed, that hexanuclear cyclic complex anions of the general composition [Ge6(µ-OH)6-n(µ-O)n(µ-hedp)6](6+n)− were present in the aqueous solutions of investigated compounds. At the same time, the composition and charge of the anion in each compound obtained in the solid state depends on the nature of the cation. They all have a common hexameric structure, with germanium atoms connected in pairs by 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonate, hydroxo-, or oxo- and hydroxo-bridges. The coordination polyhedron Ge is a curved octahedron with two six-membered GeO2P2C cycles and an eight-membered bimetallic Ge2O4P2 closing, and each ligand performs a tetradentate tris(chelate)-µ-bridging function. The ratio of formed oxo- and hydroxo-bridges and, as a result, the charge of the anion varies under the influence of cation parameters and electrosta­tic interactions. Acute and chronic toxicity studies proved the safety of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates. Complexes show a wide spectrum of pharmacological activity: antihypertensive, antiarrhythmic, hepatoprotective, cerebroprotective etc.The pharmacological and biological activities of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates(IV) are ensured by the combined action of all biologically active components, which do not compete but show synergistic action. It was concluded that the preparation of new complexes of germanium(IV) with etidronic acid by chemical modification of their composition is a promising area of research in the field of creating coordination compounds with a wide range of pharmacological effects.
doi_str_mv 10.33609/2708-129X.90.9.2024.19-30
first_indexed 2025-09-24T17:43:58Z
format Article
fulltext 19 UDC 541.49+546.814 doi: 10.33609/2708-129X.90.9.2024.19-30 STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID. Olena Martsynko1, Inna Seifullina1, Olena Finik2, Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk1,2 1Odesa I. I. Mechnikov National University, Dvoryanska St., 2, Odesa, 65082, Ukraine; 2LLC “INSPECTORAT UKRAINE”, Udilnyi lane, 1, Odesa, 65009, Ukraine e-mail: lborn@ukr.net The review article presents the results of systematic research by the authors of a number of hetero- metals and mixed-ligand 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates, their structure, biological and pharmacological properties. It was observed, that hexanuclear cyclic complex anions of the general composition [Ge6(µ-OH)6-n(µ-O)n(µ-hedp)6] (6+n)− were present in the aqueous solutions of investigated compounds. At the same time, the composition and charge of the anion in each compound obtained in the solid state depends on the nature of the cation. They all have a common hexameric structure, with germanium atoms connected in pairs by 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonate, hydroxo-, or oxo- and hydroxo-bridges. The coordination polyhedron Ge is a curved octahedron with two six-mem- bered GeO2P2C cycles and an eight-membered bimetallic Ge2O4P2 closing, and each ligand performs a tetradentate tris(chelate)-µ-bridging function. The ratio of formed oxo- and hydroxo-bridges and, as a result, the charge of the anion varies under the influence of cation parameters and electrosta tic interactions. Acute and chronic toxicity studies proved the safety of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphos- phonatogermanates. Complexes show a wide spectrum of pharmacological activity: antihypertensive, antiarrhythmic, hepatoprotective, cerebroprotective etc.The pharmacological and biological activities of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates(IV) are ensured by the combined action of all bio- logically active components, which do not compete but show synergistic action. It was concluded that the preparation of new complexes of germanium(IV) with etidronic acid by chemical modification of their composition is a promising area of research in the field of creating coordination compounds with a wide range of pharmacological effects. Keywords: germanium(IV), 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic (etidronic) acid, nitrogen hetero- cycles, coordination compounds, biological activity. INTRODUCTION. As a result of years of systematic research providedat the Ode- sa I.I.  Mechnikov National University, the au- thors have synthesized a wide range of coor- dination compounds of germanium(IV) and implemented a new approach to developing biocoordination chemistry of germanium(IV) as an independent scientific field. The com- plexes demonstrated significant advantages compared to organic compounds of germa- nium such as low toxicity, solubility in water and environmentally friendly synthetic route. 20 ISSN 2708-129X. Укр. хім. журн., 2024 STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID.INORGANIC CHEMISTRY The authors have synthesized germanium(IV) coordination compounds with O, P, N-con- taining chelating organic ligands with physi- ological activity [1, 2]. It was shown that the synergism of germanium and bioligands pro- vides their pharmacological properties. The uniqueness of germanium as a com- plexing agent and biogenic element is most clearly demonstrated by the example of 1-hyd roxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic (etidronic) acid (H4hedp), a well-known multifunctional phos- phonic complex with various valuable proper- ties used in pharmacy and cosmetology. Etidronic acid, due to its specific stereo- chemistry and mutual interaction of phos- phonic fragments, is capable of forming both monomeric complexes with s-, p-, d-, and f-element ions and coordination di-, oligo-, and polymers. Compared to other phospho nic complexing agents, a considerable number of coordination compounds of etidronic acid with various metals have been synthesized and structurally characterized using different methods [3–9]. The uniqueness of germanium as a com- plexing agent and biogenic element is most clearly demonstrated by the example of 1-hyd roxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic (etidronic) acid (H4hedp), a well-known multifunctional phos- phonic complex with various valuable pro perties used in pharmacy and cosmetology. H4hedp belongs to the class of moderately to xic substances and does not possess sensitizing or cumulative properties, which makes it suit- able for use as a pharmaceutical agent [10–14]. The high efficacy of metal coordination com- pounds with H4hedp has been demonstrated in applications for pain relief in cases of bone metastases (186Re) and the diagnosis (188Re) of bone cancer [15]. The aim of this work is analysis of the array of experimental data on the structure, biological and pharmacological properties of homo- and heterometallic, mixed-ligand 1-hydroxyethane- 1,1-diphosphonatogermanates(IV) and identify promising areas of their application. Structural insights into 1-hydroxyetha- ne-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates. Previously spectrophotometric measurements have pro ved that an acidic complex with a molar ra- tio Ge : ligand = 1:1 exists in solution in the GeO2 - H4hedp - H2O system at pH = 2 [16]. Subsequently, methods were developed for the isolation of germanium(IV) coordination compounds with ethidronic acid. It was shown that the interaction of germanium dioxide and germanium tetrachloride with H4hedp in wa- ter produces the same X-ray amorphous glassy compound. As a result of complexation, hyd rolysis of germanium tetrachloride is inhibit- ed. Detailed methods for the synthesis of vari ous types of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphospho- natogermanates(IV) are given in [1, 16–18]. The idea of introducing an outer-sphere (exo-) ligand into the reaction medium, for example, an organic molecule capable of protonation, such as nicotinic acid, nicotinamide, piracetam, etc., was proposed to obtain crystals [1]. Also, alkali and alkaline earth metals were introduced and bimetallic complexes were obtained. X-ray crystallographic data of complexes with nicotinic acid (HNic)6[Ge6(µ-OH)6(µ-hedp)6]⋅12H2O, magnesium [Mg(H2O)6]2H2[Ge6(µ-OH)6(µ-hedp)6]⋅28H2O and barium Ва3[Ge6(µ-OH)6(µ-hedp)6]·25H2O were received. It was found that the crystals of the com- pounds were based on identical hexanuclear 21https://ucj.org.ua Olena Martsynko, Inna Seifullina, Olena Finik, Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk UCJ № 9 / Vol. 90 cyclic complex anions [Ge6(µ-OH)6(µ-hedp)6] 6− (рис. 1) in which six germanium atoms are in- terconnected by six bridging ligand molecules (phosphonium groups are completely deproto- nated, each of them is connected to different germanium atoms), as well as six bridging hyd roxo-groups. The coordination polyhedron is a curved octahedron typical of tetravalent germanium. The cations are cations of NicH+ protonated on the nitrogen atom of the nico- tinic acid heterocycle and hexaquacations of s-metals. Fig. 1. Crystal structure of the anion [Ge6(µ-OH)6(µ-hedp)6] 6-[1]. In the structure Ва3[Ge6(µ-OH)6(µ-hedp)6]· 25H2O the barium atoms are coordinated ex- clusively by the oxygen atoms of water mole- cules. However, the significant disorder of all Ba2+ cations and some water molecules pre- vented the precise determination of the crystal structure, coordination number and coordina- tion polyhedron of barium atoms, and the way the structural units are packed in the crystal. The structure of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-di phosphonatogermanates(IV) of metals of other electronic units was investigated. After obtain- 22 ISSN 2708-129X. Укр. хім. журн., 2024 STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID.INORGANIC CHEMISTRY ing the structural data of the bimetallic complex with zinc, Zn4[Ge6(µ-OH)4(µ-О)2(µ-hedp)6]⋅ 38Н2О, it was found that there is a change in the structure of the hexanuclear anion (2 hydroxo-bridges out of 6 are converted to oxo-bridges). This structure also contains oc- tahedral complex zinc cations with different ligand environments: hexaquacations and cati- ons in which two of the six adjacent (cis) verti- ces of the zinc octahedron are occupied by the terminal ligand atoms of the two hexanuclear anions, and the remaining four vertices contain oxygen atoms of water molecules (Fig. 2). That is, the molecular formula of these compound can be written as [Zn4(H2O)18][Ge6(µ-OH)4(µ-О)2 (µ-Oedph)6]⋅20Н2О. The complex cations and hexanuclear ani ons are connected by an extensive network of hydrogen bonds through coordinated and crystallising water molecules. A single inde- pendent hydrogen bond is also implemented, which directly connects each hexanuclear ani- on with four neighbouring ones, thus forming a polymeric anionic layer. Fig. 2. Fragment of the domain layer [Zn(2){Ge6(μ-OH)4(μ-O)2(μ-hedp)6}]n in the crystal structure of [Zn4(H2O)18][Ge6(µ-OH)4(µ-О)2(µ-Oedph)6]⋅20Н2О. Coordination compounds with lanthanides are coordination polymers. The X-ray diffrac- tion study of three heterometallic coordina- tion polymers of general formula {Ln2[LnGe6 (μ-hedp)6(μ-O)3(μ-OH)3(H2O)4]·xH2O}n (Ln = Nd, x ∼ 26; Er, x ∼ 24; Tm, x ∼ 20) is perfor 23https://ucj.org.ua Olena Martsynko, Inna Seifullina, Olena Finik, Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk UCJ № 9 / Vol. 90 med. The basis element of structures is a hexa nuclear complex anion [Ge6(μ-hedp)6(μ-O)3 (μ-OH)3] 9−, in which bridging hydroxo- and oxo-ligands are statistically disordered with equal probability. Hexameric units are con- nected by Ln1(H2O)4 fragments into a frame- work (fig. 3). In structures are channels accom- modating disordered lanthanide atoms and water molecules. The complete disordering of lanthanide atoms in the channels and the al- most complete disordering of water molecules coordinating them do not allow us to deter- mine the actualhydrate composition of com- plexes. Fig. 3. Fragment of thestructure of {Nd2[NdGe6(μ-hedp)6(μ-O)3(μ-OH)3(H2O)4]·26H2O}n. The next step was the introduction of ad- ditional ligands (1,10-phenanthroline, phen; 2,2’-bipyridine, bipy) and the preparation of different-ligand and heterometal complexes with 3d metals. The result demonstrated the presence of the hexanuclear anion [Ge6(µ-OH)6 (µ-hedp)6] 6- (fig. 1) in the obtained compounds. However, there is a diversity in the structure of cations depending on the d-metal. Complexes with structure [{Co(рhen)3}2 {Co(рhen)(H2O)4}2][{Ge(μ-OH)(μ-hedp)}6Cl2], [{Cu(рhen)2(H2O)}2(Hрhen)2][Ge(μ-OH) (μ-hedp)]6∙20H2O were synthesized byusing the initial chlorides of 3d metals. According to X-ray diffraction data, these compound- sare cation–anion type complexes in which the anions are represented by [Ge6(μ-OH)6 (μ-hedp)6] 6– (in the case of Co-complex two additional Cl– ions too), while the cations are [Co(phen)3] 2+,[Co(phen)(H2O)4] 2+in Co-com- plex (fig. 4) and [Cu(phen)2(H2O)]2+, Hphen+ in Cu-complex (fig. 5). 24 ISSN 2708-129X. Укр. хім. журн., 2024 STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID.INORGANIC CHEMISTRY (a) (b) Fig. 4. Molecular structure of cations [Co(phen)3] 2+ (a) and [Co(phen)(H2O)4] 2+ (b). (a) (b) Fig. 5. Molecular structure of cations [Cu(phen)2(H2O)]2+ (a) and Hphen+ (b). In the crystals of compounds the cations, anions, andwater molecules are combined by numerous intermolecular hydrogen bonds, giving rise to a 3D network (fig. 6). A distinction of these coordination com- pounds from the previously studied 1-hydrox- yethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates(IV) [1] is the formation of supramolecular assem- blies based on simple and complex cations and anions, which mutually counterbalance their charges. This is caused by both the replace- ment of Co2+ by Cu2+ and the incorporation of 1,10-phenanthroline, which can function simultaneously as a bidentate chelating ligand and an outer-sphere cation in the Hp hen+ monoprotonated form. 25https://ucj.org.ua Olena Martsynko, Inna Seifullina, Olena Finik, Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk UCJ № 9 / Vol. 90 (a) (b) Fig. 6. Crystal structure of compounds [{Co(рhen)3}2{Co(рhen)(H2O)4}2][{Ge(μ-OH)(μ-hedp)}6Cl2] (a) and [{Cu(рhen)2(H2O)}2(Hрhen)2][Ge(μ-OH)(μ-hedp)]6∙20H2O (b). The developed synthesis methods allowed us to obtain Ge(IV)-3d-metals coordination compounds with 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphos- phonic acid and 2,2’-bipyridine. Complexes are characterized by the methods of elemental analysis, IR-spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis. It was established that the obtained compounds to the cation-anion type. They consist of the hexanuclear cyclic anions [Ge6 (μ-OH)4(μ-O)2(μ-hedp)6] 8-, complex cations [M(bipy)3] 2+ (М = Co, Ni), [Cu(H2O)(bipy)2] 2+ (Fig. 7) and crystallization water molecules. In the cation of complexes with Co(II) and Ni(II) the octahedral coordination polyhedron of the 3d-metals formed by the six nitrogen atoms of three 2,2´-bipyridine. The coordination num- ber of Cu atoms is five, and the polyhedron is formed by the four nitrogen atoms of two mole- cules of 2,2´-bipyridine and the oxygen atom of the water molecule. The synthesized complex- es correspond to the formulas [M(bipy)3]4[Ge6 (μ-OH)4(μ-O)2(μ-hedp)6]⋅nН2О (М = Co, n = 20; Ni, n = 12), [Cu(H2O)(bipy)2]4[Ge6(μ-OH)4 (μ-O)2(μ-hedp)6]⋅14Н2O [18]. Fig. 7. Scheme of structures of cations [M(bipy)3] 2+, [Cu(H2O)(bipy)2] 2+. 7 polyhedron is formed by the four nitrogen atoms of two molecules of 2,2´-bipyridine and the oxygen atom of the water molecule. The synthesized complexes correspond to the formulas [M(bipy)3]4[Ge6(μ-OH)4(μ-O)2(μ-hedp)6]nН2О (М = Co, n = 20; Ni, n = 12), [Cu(H2O)(bipy)2]4[Ge6(μ-OH)4(μ-O)2(μ-hedp)6]14Н2O [18]. Fig. 7. Scheme of structures of cations [M(bipy)3]2+, [Cu(H2O)(bipy)2]2+. Pharmacological and biological activity of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates(IV). The pharmacological activity of a number of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1- diphosphonatogermanates(IV), which according to the results of acute toxicity testing are classified as low-toxic, was investigated [19–22]. The specific effect of complexes with nicotinic acid and magnesium on the cardiovascular system was established on the model of arrhythmia caused by intraperitoneal administration of aconitine alkaloid to rats. The antiarrhythmic effect was found, and it was more pronounced in the complex with magnesium [23–25]. In acute cerebral ischemia caused by carotid artery occlusion, 1-hydroxyethane-1,1- diphosphonatogermanates(IV) with piracetam has a pronounced anti-ischemic effect and is also characterised by high absorption and elimination rate constants in the body [26]. A high hepatoprotective effect of the complex with nicotinic acid was also determined; it prevents changes in total cholesterol, phospholipids and maintains the qualitative and quantitative composition of phospholipid fractions at the level of control values in erythrocyte membranes and in the liver [27]. Studies of the in vitro interferonogenic activity of these compounds on a fibroblast cell culture line showed that the complex with nicotinic acid induces interferon, and at a concentration of 25 to 100 μg/ml leads to a 100% delay in the cytopathic effect of vesicular stomatitis virus in cell culture, which is superior to the comparison drugs. In the model of endotoxemia of post-traumatic genesis (which can occur, for example, in peritonitis), the detoxifying effect of the complex with magnesium was shown, which is expressed in a decrease in the level of medium-weight molecules in the blood serum – a universal marker of endogenous intoxication and lipid peroxidation products in the liver homogenate, i.e. the degree of damage to cellular and subcellular membranes [28]. The screening for hepatoprotective activity among compounds with 3d-metals revealed that the administration of the complex with copper resulted in a significantly lower increase in the activity of cytolysis and cholestasis enzymes than in untreated animals with hepatitis. The compound also reduced bilirubin levels in blood serum and liver tissue. Importantly, it has low toxicity with different types of administration: oral, intraperitoneal and subcutaneous [29–30]. It was studied the effect of mixed-ligand complexes of Ge(IV) – Co(II) (Ni(II), Cu(II)) with 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic acid and 2,2′-bipyridine on the activity of elastase and fibrinogenase isolated from Bacillus sp. IMV B-7883. It has shown that complexes Co(II) and Ni(II) inhibited the activity of elastase by 54 and 71% respectively, while complex Cu(II) enhanced it by 30%. All three complexes have a stimulating effect on fibrinogenase activity in more than 50% [18]. CONCLUSION. As a result of systematic studies of the structure of a number of mixed-ligand 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates(IV) with different metals, it was observed, that N N М N N N N 2+ M = Co, Ni N N Cu N N H2O 2+ 26 ISSN 2708-129X. Укр. хім. журн., 2024 STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID.INORGANIC CHEMISTRY Pharmacological and biological activity of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermana tes(IV). The pharmacological activity of a number of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogerma nates(IV), which according to the results of acute toxicity testing are classified as low-toxic, was investigated [19–22]. The specific effect of complexes with nico- tinic acid and magnesium on the cardiovascular system was established on the model of arrhyth- mia caused by intraperitoneal administration of aconitine alkaloid to rats. The antiarrhythmic effect was found, and it was more pronounced in the complex with magnesium [23–25]. In acute cerebral ischemia caused by carotid artery occlusion, 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphos- phonatogermanates(IV) with piracetam has a pronounced anti-ischemic effect and is also characterised by high absorption and elimina- tion rate constants in the body [26]. A high hepatoprotective effect of the com- plex with nicotinic acid was also determined; it prevents changes in total cholesterol, phospho- lipids and maintains the qualitative and quan- titative composition of phospholipid fractions at the level of control values in erythrocyte membranes and in the liver [27]. Studies of the in vitro interferonogenic ac- tivity of these compounds on a fibroblast cell culture line showed that the complex with nic- otinic acid induces interferon, and at a concen- tration of 25 to 100 μg/ml leads to a 100% delay in the cytopathic effect of vesicular stomatitis virus in cell culture, which is superior to the comparison drugs. In the model of endotoxemia of post-trau- matic genesis (which can occur, for example, in peritonitis), the detoxifying effect of the complex with magnesium was shown, which is expressed in a decrease in the level of medi- um-weight molecules in the blood serum – a universal marker of endogenous intoxication and lipid peroxidation products in the liver ho- mogenate, i.e. the degree of damage to cellular and subcellular membranes [28]. The screening for hepatoprotective activity among compounds with 3d-metals revealed that the administration of the complex with copper resulted in a significantly lower in- crease in the activity of cytolysis and cholesta- sis enzymes than in untreated animals with hepatitis. The compound also reduced bili rubin levels in blood serum and liver tissue. Importantly, it has low toxicity with different types of administration: oral, intraperitoneal and subcutaneous [29–30]. It was studied the effect of mixed-ligand complexes of Ge(IV) – Co(II) (Ni(II), Cu(II)) with 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic acid and 2,2′-bipyridine on the activity of elastase and fibrinogenase isolated from Bacillus sp. IMV B-7883. It has shown that complex- es Co(II) and Ni(II) inhibited the activity of elastase by 54 and 71% respectively, while complex Cu(II) enhanced it by 30%. All three complexes have a stimulating effect on fibrino- genase activity in more than 50% [18]. CONCLUSION. As a result of systematic stu dies of the structure of a number of mixed-li gand 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatoger manates(IV) with different metals, it was ob- served, that hexanuclear cyclic complex ani- ons of the general composition [Ge6(µ-OH)6-n (µ-O)n(µ-hedp)6] (6+n)− were present in the aque- ous solutions of investigated compounds. At the same time, the composition and charge of the anion in each compound obta ined in the solid state depends on the nature of the cation (fig. 8). 27https://ucj.org.ua Olena Martsynko, Inna Seifullina, Olena Finik, Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk UCJ № 9 / Vol. 90 Fig. 8. Synthetic route and structures of different types of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates. 8 hexanuclear cyclic complex anions of the general composition [Ge6(-OH)6-n(-O)n(-hedp)6](6+n) were present in the aqueous solutions of investigated compounds. At the same time, the composition and charge of the anion in each compound obtained in the solid state depends on the nature of the cation (fig. 8). Fig. 8. Synthetic route and structures of different types of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1- diphosphonatogermanates. They all have a common hexameric structure, with germanium atoms connected in pairs by 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonate, hydroxo-, or oxo- and hydroxo-bridges. The coordination polyhedron Ge is a curved octahedron with two six-membered GeO2P2C cycles and an eight- membered bimetallic Ge2O4P2 closing, and each ligand performs a tetradentate tris(chelate)-- bridging function. The ratio of formed oxo- and hydroxo-bridges and, as a result, the charge of the anion varies under the influence of cation parameters and electrostatic interactions. However, the structure of complex anions is quite stable and is not destroyed even by interactions with complex cations. Most obtained compounds refer to the cation-anion type with various cations (protonated organic molecules, hexaaqua-, bipyridine-, and phenanthroline metal cations). In the structure of lanthanide compounds complex hexanuclear anions [Ge6(-OH)3(-O)3(-hedp)6]9 and Ln(H2O)4 fragments are combined into a 3D-framework. The pharmacological and biological activities of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1- diphosphonatogermanates(IV) are ensured by the combined action of all biologically active components, which do not compete but show synergistic action. In view of the above, it can be concluded that the preparation of new complexes of germanium(IV) with etidronicacid by chemical modification of their composition is a promising area of research in the field of creating coordination compounds with a wide range of pharmacological effects. GeO2 + Н4hedp 900C, H2O + L, pH 4 + MHCO3, pH 5 + M’CO3, pH 3.5 or 5 + M’’Cl2 + phen (ethanol) + M’’(CH3COO)2 pH 3.5 + M’’(CH3COO)2 + bipy (ethanol) + Ln(CH3COO)3, pH 4 An = Ge6(µ-OH)4(µ-O)2(µ-hedp)6 8- [M’’(H2O)6]4[An] [Co/Ni(bipy)3]4[An] [Cu(bipy)2(H2O)]4[An] {Ln2[Ln(H2O)4Ge6(µ-OH)3(µ-O)3(µ-hedp)6]}n [Ge6(µ-OH)6-n(µ-O)n(µ-hedp)6](6+n)- (in solution) L= nicotinic acid, niacinamide, isoniazid, imidazole, piracetam; M = Na, K; M’ = Mg, Ca, Sr, Ba; M’’ = Co(II), Ni(II), Cu(II), Zn; Ln = Nd(III), Er(III), Tm(III); bipy – 2,2’-bipyridine; phen – 1,10-phenanthroline; *all compounds are hydrates An = Ge6(µ-OH)6(µ-hedp)6 6- (HL)6[An]*, M6[An] [M’(H2O)6]2H2[An] [M’(H2O)6]3[An] [{Co(рhen)3}2{Co(рhen)(H2O)4}2][AnCl2] [{Cu(рhen)2(H2O)}2(Hрhen)2][An] They all have a common hexameric struc- ture, with germanium atoms connected in pairs by 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonate, hydroxo-, or oxo- and hydroxo-bridges. The coordination polyhedron Ge is a curved oc- tahedron with two six-membered GeO2P2C cycles and an eight-membered bimetallic Ge2O4P2 closing, and each ligand performs a tetradentate tris(chelate)-µ-bridging function. The ratio of formed oxo- and hydroxo-bridges and, as a result, the charge of the anion varies under the influence of cation parameters and electrostatic interactions. However, the struc- ture of complex anions is quite stable and is not destroyed even by interactions with complex cations. Most obtained compounds refer to the ca tion-anion type with various cations (proto- nated organic molecules, hexaaqua-, bipyri- dine-, and phenanthroline metal cations). In the structure of lanthanide compounds com- plex hexanuclear anions [Ge6(µ-OH)3(µ-O)3 (µ-hedp)6] 9− and Ln(H2O)4 fragments are com- bined into a 3D-framework. The pharmacological and biological acti vities of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonato- germanates(IV) are ensured by the combined action of all biologically active components, 28 ISSN 2708-129X. Укр. хім. журн., 2024 STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID.INORGANIC CHEMISTRY which do not compete but show synergistic action. In view of the above, it can be concluded that the preparation of new complexes of ger- manium(IV) with etidronicacid by chemical modification of their composition is a prom- ising area of research in the field of creating coordination compounds with a wide range of pharmacological effects. This work was done according to the theme “Chemical construction of or- gano-inorganic ensembles of coordi- nating, supramolecular, polymeric na- ture for use as new materials and phar- maceuticals”, No state registration: 0122U201403, 2022-2026. ОСОБЛИВОСТІ БУДОВИ ТА ФАРМАКОЛОГІЧНІ ВЛАСТИВОСТІ КОМПЛЕКСІВ ГЕРМАНІЮ(IV) З 1-ГІДРОКСИЕТАН-1,1-ДИФОСФОНОВОЮ КИСЛОТОЮ О. Марцинко1, І. Сейфулліна1, О. Фінік2, К. Цимбалюк1,2 1Одеський національний університет імені І. І. Мечникова, вул. Дворянська, 2, Одеса 65082, Україна; 2ТОВ «ІНСПЕКТОРАТ УКРАЇНА», провулок Удільний, 1, м. Одеса 65009, Україна e-mail: lborn@ukr.net В оглядовій статті представлено резуль- тати систематичних досліджень авторів низки гетерометалів і різнолігандних 1-гід роксиетан-1,1-дифосфонатогерманатів, їх ньої структури, біологічних і фармаколо- гічних властивостей. Встановлено, що у водних розчинах досліджуваних сполук присутні шестиядерні циклічні комплекс ні аніони загального складу [Ge6(µ-OH)6-n (µ-O)n(µ-hedp)6] (6+n)−. При цьому склад і заряд аніона в кожній сполуці, отрима- ній в твердому стані, залежить від при- роди катіона. Усі вони мають спільну гек- самерну структуру аніона, в якій атомами германію попарно з’єднані 1-гідроксие- тан-1,1-дифосфонатними, гідроксо- або оксо- та гідроксомістками. Координацій- ний поліедр Ge є викривленим октаедром з двома шестичленними циклами GeO2P2C та восьмичленним біметалічним циклом Ge2O4P2, кожен ліганд виконує тетрадентат- нутрис(хелатну)-µ-місткову функцію. Спів- відношення утворених оксо- і гідроксоміст- ків і, як наслідок, заряд аніона змінюється під впливом параметрів катіонів і електро- статичних взаємодій. Дослідження гострої та хронічної токсичності довели безпеч- ність 1-гідроксиетан-1,1-дифосфонатогер- манатів. Комплекси виявляють широкий спектр фармакологічної дії: антигіпертен- зивну, антиаритмічну, гепатопротекторну, церебропротекторну та ін. Фармакологіч- на та біологічна активність 1-гідроксие- тан-1,1-дифосфонатогерманатів(IV) забез- печується спільною дією всіх біологічно активних компонентів, які не конкурують, а виявляють синергічний ефект. Зроблено висновок, що отримання нових комплек- сів германію(IV) з етидроновою кислотою шляхом хімічної модифікації їхнього скла- ду є перспективним напрямком досліджень у галузі створення координаційних сполук із широким спектром фармакологічної дії. Ключові слова: германій(IV), 1-гідрок сиетан-1,1-дифосфонова (етидронова) кис- лота, нітрогенвмісні гетероцикли, коорди- наційні сполуки, біологічна активність. 29https://ucj.org.ua Olena Martsynko, Inna Seifullina, Olena Finik, Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk UCJ № 9 / Vol. 90 REFERENCES 1. Martsіnko E.E., Seifullina I.I. Design and syn- thesis of molecular complexes and complexo nates of germanium(IV) with a wide spectrum of pharmacological action. 2018. Odesa. ONU. (іn Ukranian). 2. SeifullinaI.I., Martsinko E.E., Afanasenko E.V. Design and synthesis of new homo- and het- erometal coordination compounds of germa- nium(IV) for preparation of low toxic drugs with a wide the rapeuticaction. Visn. Odes. nac. univ., Him. 2015. 20(4): 6–17. https://doi.org/10.18524/2304-0947.2015. 4(56).56690 3. Bouhsina S., Buglyó P., AbiAad E., Aboukais A., Kiss T. Formation of oligonuclear complex- es between copper(II) and 1-hydroxyethane- 1,1-diphosphonic acid. Inorganica Chim Acta. 2004. 357(1): 305–310. doi:10.1016/s0020-1693(03)00445-6 4. Reed W.A., Rao L., Zanonato P., Garnov A.Y., Powell B.A., Nash K.L. Complexation of UVI with 1-Hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic Aci- din Acidicto Basic Solutions. Inorg. Chem. 2007. 46(7): 2870–2876. doi:10.1021/ic0621401 5. Wang W.N., Sun Z.G., Zhu Y.Y., Dong D.P. et al. Hydrothermal synthesis, structures, and lumi- nescent properties of four new zinc(II) diphos- phonate hybrids with mixed ligands. Cryst Eng. Comm. 2011. 13(20): 6099–6106. doi: 10.1039/C1CE05291H. 6. Liu B., Ding T., Hua W.J., Liu X.M., Hu H.M., Li S.H., Zheng L.M. Diruthenium(III, III) diphos- phonate with a spinground state S = 2. Dalton Trans. 2013. 42(10): 3429–3433. doi: 10.1039/C2DT32306K 7. Sun S.H., Sun Z.G., Zhu Y.Y., Dong D.P., Jiao C.Q., Zhu J., Li J., Chu W., Tian H., Zheng M.J., Shao W.Y., Lu Y.F. Four Novel Oxomolybde- num-Organodiphosphonate Hybrids in the Presence of Cu(II)–Organonitrogen Building Blocks: Synthesis, Crystal Structures, and Sur- face Photovoltage Properties. Cryst. Growth. Des. 2013. 13(11): 226–238. doi: 10.1021/cg301392p 8. Liao Z., Ling J., Reinke L., Szymanowski J. Sig- mon G., Burns G. Cage clusters built from ura- nyl ions bridged through peroxo and 1-hydro xyethane-1,1-diphosphonic acid ligands. Dal- ton Trans. 2013. 42(19): 6793–6799. doi: 10.1039/c3dt33025g. 9. Jiao C.Q., Zhao Z., Ma C., Sun Z.G., Dong D.P., Zhu Y.Y., Li J. Chiral and Achiral Copper(II) Carboxyphosphonates Supramolecular Struc- tures: Synthesis, Structures, Surface Photovol tage, and Magnetic Properties. Cryst. Growth. Des. 2016. 16(10): 5624–5635. doi: 10.1021/acs.cgd.6b00197. 10. Ma K.R., Yin J.Z., Hu H., Kan Y.H. Synthe- ses, Structures and Fluorescent Properties of TwoZn(II)-Diphosphonate Coordination Po lymers. J Clust. Sci. 2021. 32: 875–886. doi: 10.1007/s10876-020-01854-z. 11. Saji H., Ogawa K., Kitamura Y., Kubota-Akiza- wa M., Kawashima H. Chemical Control of Bi- ological Activity and Biodistribution of Metal Compounds: Drug Design of Metal Complexes with Biological Activity and Target-Specific Bi- odistribution. Biomed. Res. Trace. Elem. 2007. 18(3): 255–263. doi: 10.11299/brte.18.255 12. Campello A., Rodrigues R., Alves F., Miranda K., Brum S., Mdala I., Siqueira J., Rôças I. Enhanc- ing the Intracanal Antibacterial Effects of Sodi- um Hypochlorite with Etidronic Acidor Citric Acid. J Endodontics. 2022. 48(9): 1161–1168. doi:10.1016/j.joen.2022.06.006. 13. Bajpe S., Shetty C., Shetty A., Kaur G., Saji S.A., Prabha C. Scanning electronmicroscopy eval- uation of smear layer removal using ethylen- ediaminetetraacetic acid, etidronic acid, and chitosan nanoparticle solution as root canal irrigants. Endodontology. 2023. 35(1): 48–53. doi:10.4103/endo.endo_126_22. 14. Supraja A., Arali V., Rapala H., Vemagiri C., Kallakuri M., Kumar G. Evaluation of Anti- microbial Efficacy of Etidronic Acid against Enterococcus faecalis in Primary Teeth: An In Vivo Study. Intern J Clinical Pediatric Dentistry. 2024. 17(4): 433–436. doi: 10.5005/jp-journals-10005-2834. 30 ISSN 2708-129X. Укр. хім. журн., 2024 STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID.INORGANIC CHEMISTRY 15. Petriev V.M. Influence of reactant concentra- tions and solution acidity on the complexation of 188Re with 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphospho nic acid. Radiochemistry. 2008. 50: 203–206. doi: 10.1134/S1066362208020227. 16. Martsіnko Е.E. Synthesis, structure and pros- pects of application of homo- and heterome- tallic 1-hydroxyethylidenediphosphonateger manates. Ukr. Chem. J. 2014. 80(8): 88–95. (іn Ukrainian). 17. Martsynko О.E., Seifullina I.I. Double Ge(IV)- Co(ІІ) complexes with 1-hydroxyethylidene- di phosphonic acid and 2,2′-bipyridine. Vіsn. Odes. Nac. Unіv. Hіm. 2022. 27(1): 31–38. doi:10.18524/2304-0947.2022.1(81).255828. (іn Ukrainian). 18. Gudzenko О., Varbanets L., Seifullina I., Mar tsynko О., Tsymbalyuk K. Мixed-ligand com- plexes of germanium – 3d-metal with 1-hyd roxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic acidаnd 2,2′-bi- pyridine as modulators of Bacillussp. IMV B-7883 elastase and fibrinogenase activity. Ukr. Biochem. J. 2024. 96(1): 96–102. doi:10.15407/ubj96.01.096. 19. Kresyun V., Seifullina I., Vidavska G., Shemo naeva K. Prospects for the creation of new drugs based on oxyethylidene diphosphonic acid. Medical chemistry. 2004. 6(3): 133–138. (іn Ukrainian). 20. Godovan V.V., Kresyun V.Y., Seifullina I.I. Comparative pharmacological activity of new biologically active substances – derivatives of diphosphonicacids. Integrative anthropology. 2007. 2(10): 13–17. (іn Ukrainian). 21. Kresyun V., Godovan V.,Seifullina I. Influence of oxyethylidene diphosphonate germanate derivatives on the phospholipid composition of membranes in toxic liver damage. J. Aca demy Med. Sci. Ukraine. 2008. 14(1): 63–71. (іn Ukrainian). 22. Lukianchuk V., Seifullina I., Litvinenko D., Martsynko O. Pharmacological properties of organic and coordination germanium com- pounds – modern concepts. Pharmacology and Drug Toxicology. 2016. 1(47): 3–13. (іn Ukrai nian). 23. Godovan V.V., Kresyun V.Y., Seifullina I.I. Ti ssue respiration and oxidative phosphoryla tionin heart mitochondriain experimental myocardial dystrophyandits drug correction. Odes’kij medični jžurnal. 2006. 3(95): 13–17. (іn Ukrainian). 24. Godovan V.V., Kresyun V.Y., Seifullina I.I. Bio- logically active antiarrhythmic substance ger- macord (UA Patent No. 20658). Ukraine. 2007. (іn Ukrainian). 25. Godovan V.V., Kresyun V.Y., Seifullina I.I. Magnesium oxyethylidene diphosphonato-ger- manate characterised by vasodilatoraction (UA Patent No. 19965). Ukraine. 2007. (іn Ukraini- an). 26. Lukianchuk V.D., Krylova O.E., Seifullina I.I., Martsynko O.E., Tkachenko V.M. 2-Oxo-1- pyrrolidinyl acetamide hydroxyethylidene di- phosphonate germanate(IV) with cerebropro- tective activity (UA Patent No. 45070). Ukraine. 2009. (іn Ukrainian). 27. Godovan V.V., Kresyun V.Y., Seifullina I.I. Nicogerm - a biologically active hepatoprotec- tive substance (UA Patent No.51482). Ukraine. 2010. (іn Ukrainian). 28. Lukianchuk V.D., Seifullina I.I., Rysukhina N.V., Martsynko O.E. Method of detoxifica- tion of the body in case of endotoxicosis of post-traumatic origin by a complex compound based on germanium, magnesium and ox- yethylidenediphosphonic acid (UA Patent No. 36684). Ukraine. 2008. (іn Ukrainian). 29. Tymchyshyn O.L., Godovan V.V., Seifullina I.I. A cute toxicity of medgerm – a new derivative of germanium salt of diphosphonic acid with copper. Odes’kij medični jžurnal. 2010. 2(118): 23–26. (іn Ukrainian). 30. Tymchyshyn O.L., Godovan V.V., Kresyun V..Y, Seifullina I.I., Martsynko O.E. Medgerm – a biologically active hepatoprotective substance (UAPatent No. 66392). Ukraine. 2011. (іn Uk rainian). Стаття надійшла 10.06.2024.
id oai:ojs2.1444248.nisspano.web.hosting-test.net:article-688
institution Ukrainian Chemistry Journal
keywords_txt_mv keywords
language English
last_indexed 2026-07-23T01:12:08Z
publishDate 2024
publisher V.I.Vernadsky Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry
record_format ojs
resource_txt_mv ucjorgua/40/c71dda87a18e60dd33aa50ba0558b040.pdf
spelling oai:ojs2.1444248.nisspano.web.hosting-test.net:article-6882026-07-22T08:23:55Z STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review) Martsynko, Olena Seifullina, Inna Finik, Оlena Tsymbaliuk, Kyrylo germanium(IV), 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic (etidronic) acid, nitrogen heterocycles, coordination compounds, biological activity.   The review article presents the results of systematic research by the authors of a number of heterometals and mixed-ligand 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates, their structure, biological and pharmacological properties. It was observed, that hexanuclear cyclic complex anions of the general composition [Ge6(µ-OH)6-n(µ-O)n(µ-hedp)6](6+n)− were present in the aqueous solutions of investigated compounds. At the same time, the composition and charge of the anion in each compound obtained in the solid state depends on the nature of the cation. They all have a common hexameric structure, with germanium atoms connected in pairs by 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonate, hydroxo-, or oxo- and hydroxo-bridges. The coordination polyhedron Ge is a curved octahedron with two six-membered GeO2P2C cycles and an eight-membered bimetallic Ge2O4P2 closing, and each ligand performs a tetradentate tris(chelate)-µ-bridging function. The ratio of formed oxo- and hydroxo-bridges and, as a result, the charge of the anion varies under the influence of cation parameters and electrosta­tic interactions. Acute and chronic toxicity studies proved the safety of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates. Complexes show a wide spectrum of pharmacological activity: antihypertensive, antiarrhythmic, hepatoprotective, cerebroprotective etc.The pharmacological and biological activities of 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonatogermanates(IV) are ensured by the combined action of all biologically active components, which do not compete but show synergistic action. It was concluded that the preparation of new complexes of germanium(IV) with etidronic acid by chemical modification of their composition is a promising area of research in the field of creating coordination compounds with a wide range of pharmacological effects. V.I.Vernadsky Institute of General and Inorganic Chemistry 2024-10-25 Article Article Inorganic Chemistry Неорганическая химия Неорганічна хімія application/pdf https://ucj.org.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/688 10.33609/2708-129X.90.9.2024.19-30 Ukrainian Chemistry Journal; Vol. 90 No. 9 (2024): Ukrainian Chemistry Journal; 19-30 Украинский химический журнал; ##issue.vol## 90 ##issue.no## 9 (2024): Ukrainian Chemistry Journal; 19-30 Український хімічний журнал; Том 90 № 9 (2024): Ukrainian Chemistry Journal; 19-30 2708-129X 2708-1281 en https://ucj.org.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/688/342 Copyright (c) 2024 Olena Martsynko, Inna Seifullina, Оlena Finik, Kyrylo Tsymbaliuk https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0
spellingShingle Martsynko, Olena
Seifullina, Inna
Finik, Оlena
Tsymbaliuk, Kyrylo
STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review)
title STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review)
title_full STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review)
title_fullStr STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review)
title_full_unstemmed STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review)
title_short STRUCTURE FEATURES AND PHARMACOLOGICAL PROPERTIES OF GERMANIUM(IV) COMPLEXES WITH 1-HYDROXYETHANE-1,1-DIPHOSPHONIC ACID(Review)
title_sort structure features and pharmacological properties of germanium(iv) complexes with 1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic acid(review)
topic_facet germanium(IV)
1-hydroxyethane-1,1-diphosphonic (etidronic) acid
nitrogen heterocycles
coordination compounds
biological activity.
url https://ucj.org.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/688
work_keys_str_mv AT martsynkoolena structurefeaturesandpharmacologicalpropertiesofgermaniumivcomplexeswith1hydroxyethane11diphosphonicacidreview
AT seifullinainna structurefeaturesandpharmacologicalpropertiesofgermaniumivcomplexeswith1hydroxyethane11diphosphonicacidreview
AT finikolena structurefeaturesandpharmacologicalpropertiesofgermaniumivcomplexeswith1hydroxyethane11diphosphonicacidreview
AT tsymbaliukkyrylo structurefeaturesandpharmacologicalpropertiesofgermaniumivcomplexeswith1hydroxyethane11diphosphonicacidreview